Interviewing with Confidence Mindset and Confidence

Confidence vs Competence in Interviews: Why Both Matter

Being skilled is just the start. Confidence is what gets you hired. Stop waiting for the interviewer to notice your skills and start showing them you are the answer they need.

Focus and Planning

What to Expect if You Use the 'Cure' Method

  • 01
    Confidence Becomes Your Value When you show you are sure of yourself, employers see you are willing to put in Extra Effort. This makes you seem more valuable because leaders want people who will always do more than the minimum required.
  • 02
    Self-Belief Speeds Things Up Speaking clearly builds trust right away and makes the hiring process faster. This gives you higher Speed in your career, meaning you start working on important projects sooner.
  • 03
    Strong Mindset Becomes Your Value When you stay calm under pressure, it shows you have the Strength to handle hard times at work. Companies see this as a safe choice because they know you can keep doing good work even when things are tough.
  • 04
    Your Stability Benefits the Company A confident person is more likely to teach others and stay put when things change. By keeping and sharing Important Company Knowledge, you give the company a better long-term benefit for hiring you.

Looking Closely at Interviews

The normal way people interview is based on a bad idea: that your past work should just speak for itself. This is a slow way to look for a job, assuming only your skills matter. Depending only on what you've done before to get a job is like taking out a loan you can't pay back right now. This way of thinking makes the interviewer work hard to guess how good you could be, which creates a big problem in how they judge risk.

When you show you are skilled but not sure of yourself, you make the conversation cost more. Every second you pause or sound too modest is taken as a sign you aren't fully in charge. To the hiring person, a candidate who is just "quietly good" is a big gamble. According to a CareerBuilder survey, 67% of employers say failure to make eye contact is a common nonverbal mistake in interviews, and 38% cite not smiling. These small confidence signals carry more weight than most candidates realize.

The only way to stop this is to take the job of proving your worth off the interviewer. Your only job is to pass on all your certainty to them. You need to stop just listing your skills and start showing up as a sure solution to their problems. Adopting a growth mindset approach to interviewing can help you make this shift. When you take care of the interviewer's worry, you stop being a risk and become the only obvious choice.

What Is the Difference Between Confidence and Competence?

Competence is your actual ability to do the job, built through training, education, and experience. Confidence is how clearly you communicate that ability and how much certainty you project when talking about your skills. Both matter in interviews because hiring managers need to see your skills and believe you can apply them under pressure.

A 2019 study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology by researchers Peter Belmi (University of Virginia) and Margaret Neale (Stanford Graduate School of Business) tested this across four studies with a combined 152,661 participants. They found that overconfident individuals were consistently perceived as more competent and more hirable, even when their actual performance was no better than less confident peers. The takeaway for job seekers: your skills open the door, but your confidence is what convinces the hiring manager to let you through it.

Checking Your Interview Moves

1

The One Who Just Waits

What It Looks Like

You give answers that are right on the technical side, but you wait for the interviewer to figure out what that means for them. You think that if you answer correctly, they will automatically know you are the best fit.

The Hidden Cost

You make the interviewer do the hard work of judging your value, which they see as you not being ready or not caring enough about their company's issues.

What to Do Instead

Be the Leader of the Story

Stop waiting for them to find your value. After you answer a question, clearly explain how that skill or experience solves a problem they currently have. You must take charge in showing how your past wins will create future success for their team.

2

The One Who Hides Their Wins

What It Looks Like

You often say "we" instead of "I" when talking about successes, or you make your wins sound small by saying it was "just my job." You worry that talking about your own success will seem too proud or dishonest.

The Hidden Cost

Hiring managers can't hire a "team"; they hire one person. Hiding behind the group makes it impossible for them to see what you specifically contributed, making the hiring risk bigger.

What to Do Instead

Clearly State Your Role

Be specific about your part in every group success you mention. Use a simple format: What I did, Why I did it, and What happened next. Replacing "we" with "I" for your specific tasks gives them the proof they need to feel safe hiring you.

3

Giving Answers That Sound Weak

What It Looks Like

You often start by saying "I think," "I believe," or "In my opinion," even when talking about things you've done a hundred times. You use these soft words so you don't sound too sure of yourself or like you might be wrong.

The Hidden Cost

Using unsure words makes the interviewer feel your own doubt. They see your lack of certainty as a sign that you will need constant checking and guidance.

What to Do Instead

Speak With Certainty

Practice making strong statements about your work. Instead of saying "I think I can handle that," say "I have handled similar problems by doing X, and I will use that exact method here." Change your goal to giving them a "Transfer of Certainty," where your calm and direct way of speaking makes the interviewer feel sure that the problem is already solved. Visualization techniques can help you rehearse this mindset before the interview.

The Test to See Your Confidence Level

Self-Check Chart

When jobs are competitive, just being skilled (competent) is not enough to get hired; you have to pay the admission fee. The thing that decides who gets the job is usually confidence, meaning how well you show you can handle the stress of the job. This chart compares the "Skilled Person Who Hesitates" (good skill, low confidence) with the "Trusted Worker" (good skill, high confidence).

What You Do

How You Talk

Why It Happens

Your answers are right, but full of "umms," "I think," and "maybe." You wait for them to let you speak.

The Good Outcome

The Trusted Worker (New Way)

The Fix

Answers are clear and structured, using "I did this" or "the result was." You lead the story with clear facts.

What You Do

How They See You

Why It Happens

The interviewer feels like they have to "watch over" your answers or dig hard to find your real value.

The Good Outcome

The Trusted Worker (New Way)

The Fix

The interviewer immediately feels relieved, knowing they can give you a task and you will handle it yourself.

What You Do

When You Have Gaps

Why It Happens

You get defensive or apologize when asked about a skill you lack, making the gap seem like a big problem.

The Good Outcome

The Trusted Worker (New Way)

The Fix

You briefly admit the gap and immediately switch to how your existing skills help you learn and solve the problem.

What You Do

How You Judge Success

Why It Happens

Your goal is to "pass the test" and prove you aren't a bad hire. You focus on not messing up.

The Good Outcome

The Trusted Worker (New Way)

The Fix

Your goal is to show you are a "fix" for their specific problems. You focus on the good things you will bring.

What You Do

How You Act Together

Why It Happens

You treat the interview like a student talking to a teacher, looking for them to approve of you.

The Good Outcome

The Trusted Worker (New Way)

The Fix

You treat the interview like a meeting between two equals trying to solve a business problem together.

The Main Point

Being skilled just gets you in the door. The thing that really gets you hired for good jobs is confidence, showing you can handle the stress of the job. Moving from the Old Way to the New Way means you go from being a "risky guess" to a "smart investment."

The Hidden Issues with Confidence

The Downsides

Even though acting confident is a great tactic, pushing confidence isn't a perfect solution. It can cause problems if you aren't careful.

"If you evaluate on confidence, you're likely to choose well-heeled slick talkers over those with the skills to do the job."
— Margaret Neale, Professor of Organizational Behavior, Stanford Graduate School of Business

The Big Drop (A Bad Scenario)

There is a specific Bad Scenario where your confidence is much bigger than your real skills. This is the trap of "pretend you know it until you actually know it." Confidence might get you hired, but if the difference between what you promised (confidence) and what you can actually do (skill) is too big, you will fail quickly and obviously on the job.

The Wall of Criticism (A Limit)

Confidence is great until it starts looking like being bossy. From a risk point of view, a hiring manager might worry that someone too sure of themselves won't listen to advice or admit mistakes. If you seem too certain, it causes problems in teams that value learning and working together. Learning to reframe failure as a learning opportunity can help you project confidence without crossing into arrogance.

The Wrong Situation (You Must Change Your Style)

Different jobs and company cultures need different levels of "loudness" for your confidence. This is where Switching comes in. For a sales job, high confidence is needed. But for a detail-oriented job (like handling security data or money), being too bold can be a bad sign. In those jobs, being cautious is usually more important than being flashy.

The Balanced View

To avoid the Big Drop, confidence should be a way to show your skills, not replace them. Always back up your "I can do it" attitude with real examples of things you have done. To lower the risk of sounding too critical, mix your confidence with "being smart enough to learn." Admit a time you were wrong or a skill you are currently trying to get better at. This shows you are confident enough to be humble. Finally, look up the company culture before the interview. You must be able to turn your confidence up or down to match what the job needs. Don't use the same personality for every situation.

Common Questions

What is the difference between confidence and competence?

Competence is your actual ability to do the job, built through training, education, and experience. Confidence is how clearly you communicate that ability and how much certainty you project when talking about your skills.

Both matter in interviews because hiring managers need to see your skills and believe you can apply them under pressure. Research from Stanford GSB confirms that interviewers often equate confidence with competence, even when there's no objective difference in performance.

Can introverts show confidence in interviews?

Yes. Being confident isn't about being the loudest person or acting outgoing. In an interview, confidence means being clear. You can be quiet and still be sure about what you know.

Focus on giving answers that are direct and specific. When you speak calmly about how you fix problems, the interviewer feels the certainty you are offering.

How can I talk about my achievements without seeming like I'm bragging?

Bragging is making vague claims about being "the best." Confidence is stating clear facts about the results you actually got.

To avoid sounding too proud, focus on the "team" and the "process." Describe the problem the company had, the exact steps you took to solve it, and the good result. When you present your success as a helpful story about how you helped a past employer, it sounds like a helpful example instead of showing off.

What should I do if I get a technical question and I don't know the answer?

Confidence doesn't mean you know every single fact; it means you trust your ability to find the answer.

If you are stuck, don't panic or apologize. Explain your thinking process instead. Say something like, "I haven't used that specific tool, but here is how I would start learning it based on other systems I know." This shows you are a reliable problem solver, which is more trustworthy than just knowing a random fact.

Can too much confidence hurt you in an interview?

Yes. Overconfidence backfires when the gap between what you promise and what you can deliver is too large. It can also look like arrogance if you seem unwilling to take feedback or admit mistakes.

The best approach is to back up every confident statement with a specific example from your past work, and show that you are open to learning. This balance between self-assurance and humility is what makes a candidate feel like a safe, smart hire.

Stop waiting to be found.

The idea that "your work should speak for itself" is old-fashioned and often causes good candidates to be passed over. Your technical skills get you allowed to play, but your confidence is what actually wins the job.

Instead of hoping an interviewer will "notice" your talent, start the process of giving them certainty. LinkedIn's 2024 recruiting data shows that soft skills like relationship development are now 54 times more likely to be listed as required in job posts. Your goal is to stop being a mystery in their mind and start being the clear answer to their problems.

Start Proving You're Sure